Skip to main content

Table 3 Statistical comparison of relevant parameters operation vs. conservative group

From: Operative vs. conservative treatment of AC-Joint Dislocations Rockwood grade ≥ III -An economical and clinical evaluation-

 

Operative group

Non-operative group

 
 

N

 

N

P value

Number of medical consultations

6.50 [4.14]

(3;13)

7

3.29 [1.60] (2;6)

7

0.0798

Total medical services including surgery (USD)

11’012.49 [7’845.71] (5’026.51;26’460.76)

7

1’164.27 [228.84] (892.37;1’487.48)

7

0.0061*

Cost of medicines (USD)

103.26 [46.50] (72.41;156.74)

3

70.44 [41.17] (25.53;116.43)

6

0.2736

Number of physiotherapeutic treatments

37.50 [18.37] (18;72)

7

23.14 [10.21] (9;36)

7

0.0958

Cost of physiotherapeutic treatments (USD)

1’824.41 [935.26] (875.72;3’594.31)

7

1’034.80 [347.22] (410.90;1’345.21)

7

0.0582

Days of hospitalization (days)

3.33 [1.03] (2;5)

7

0 [0] (0;0)

7

< 0.0001*

Nursing cost (USD)

48.58 [27.00] (464.71;7’999.32)

7

37.71 [27.27] (4.28;67.67)

6

0.4862

Incapacity for work (days)

370.00 [363.32] (6;91)

6

205.65 [33.49] (0;75)

6

0.2564

Salary per day (USD)

19’138.70 [23’186.43] (84.92;1’019.10)

6

6’699.36 [4’610.02]

(169.85;245.15)

6

0.2264

Calculated loss of earnings (USD)

30’262.30 [24’591.41] (509.55;59’107.80)

7

7’834.72 [5’026.33] (0.00;13’503.08)

7

0.0358*

Total cost (USD)

6.62 [4.22] (7’132.38;71’512.80)

7

3.35 [1.63] (1’582.05;15’929.14)

7

0.0798

  1. CHF, Swiss Francs; USD, US Dollar
  2. The conversion of CHF into USD was done using the current monthly average rate of 1 USD to 0.9813 CHF in July 2022
  3. Values are mean [standard deviation] (range)
  4. * Significant p value for comparison of operative group vs. Non-operative group
  5. (Chi-square test or Welch’s t-test)