Skip to main content

Table 8 Results of scenario analyses

From: Cost-effectiveness of 20-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine compared with 23-valent pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine among adults in a Norwegian setting

 

Total incremental cost (EUR)

Total incremental QALYs gained

ICER (cost per QALY gained)

∆ICER (%) compared to base case

Base case analysis

-73,607,345

7,966

-9,240

-

Efficacy and waning of PPV23 vaccine using estimates by Lawrence et al.

-59,801,031

7,341

-8,146

+ 12%

Vaccine coverage 25%

-24,535,782

2,655

-9,240

-

Vaccine coverage 50%

-49,071,563

5,311

-9,240

-

Vaccine coverage 100%

-98,143,127

10,622

-9,240

-

PCV20 serotype coverage against pneumonia:

Benfield et al. (16.9% for all age groups)

-69,346,273

7,881

-8,799

+ 5%

PCV20 serotype coverage against pneumonia:

Theilacker et al. (20.7% 18–64 years and 15.2% +65 years)

-66,352,656

7,615

-8,713

+ 6%

Time horizon 5 years

3,027,134

2,107

1,437

+ 116%

Time horizon 10 years

-45,175,157

4,474

-10,098

-9%

Discount rate 0%

-109,818,187

12,119

-9,062

+ 2%

Discount rate 7%

-53,778,375

6,185

-8,695

+ 6%

Disutility of IPD increased by 100%

-73,607,345

8,097

-9,091

+ 2%

PCV20 compared with no vaccination

19,529,114

8,519

2,292

+ 125%

PCV 20 linear waning to 0%, year 5–15

-48.964.932

6.468

-7,570

+ 18%

Herd immunity effect set to 0%

-75,156,959

8,017

-9,313

-1%

  1. Note: The table shows the results of the scenario analyses according to the total incremental costs and QALYs between PCV20 and PPV23 and the calculated ICER
  2. ICER: Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio; QALY: Quality-adjusted life years; IPD: Invasive pneumococcal diseases; PCV20: 20-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine; PPV23: 23-valent pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine