Skip to main content

Table 1 Estimated Effects of Interventions (based on model of AMRA region) and assumed Compliance data that were inputted into POPMOD model.

From: Prevention, screening and treatment of colorectal cancer: a global and regional generalized cost effectiveness analysis

Intervention

Description

Decrease

in Incidence

Decrease

in

Case-Fatality Rate

Compliance

FOB1

Annual Fecal Occult Blood Testsa

35.0%

0%

56.8%

FOB2

Biannual Fecal Occult Blood Testsa

21.9%

0%

61.8%

SIG5

Sigmoidoscopy every 5 years[1]a

38.9%

0%

45.0%

COL10

Colonoscopy every 10 yearsa

52.6%

0%

45.0%

FOB1SIG5

Annual FOBT, SIG every 5 yearsa

51.5%

0%

45.0%

FOB50

FOBT at age 50a

2.6%

0%

71.8%

SIG50

Sigmoidoscopy at age 50a

11.8%

0%

55.0%

COL50

Colonoscopy at age 50a

25.9%

0%

55.0%

FOBSIG50

FOBT & SIG at age 50a

13.2%

0%

55.0%

RX

Medical Treatment of cancersb

0%

91.9%

100%

FOB1RX

Combination of FOB1 & RX

35.0%

17.9%c

56.8%

FOB2RX

Combination of FOB2 & RX

21.9%

12.9%c

61.8%

SIG5RX

Combination of SIG5 & RX

38.9%

3.4%c

45.0%

COL10RX

Combination of COL10 & RX

52.6%

3.9%c

45.0%

FOB1SIG5RX

Combination of FOB1SIG5 & RX

51.5%

18.3%c

45.0%

FOB50RX

Combination of FOB50 & RX

2.6%

0.5%c

71.8%

SIG50RX

Combination of SIG50& RX

11.8%

0.3%c

55.0%

COL50RX

Combination of COL50& RX

25.9%

0.4%c

55.0%

FOBSIG50RX

Combination of FOBSIG50 & RX

13.2%

0.5%c

55.0%

FVCAMP

Fruit & Vegetables campaign

d)

0%

---

FVCAMPRX

Combination of FVCAMP & RX

d)

0%c

---

DRE1

Digital Rectal Exam annuallya

17.6%

0%

50%

DRE1RX

Combination of DRE1 & RX

17.6%

1.8%c

50%

  1. Notes:
  2. Subscripts 1,2,5,10 (eg: SIG5] in the intervention column denote the frequency of screening in years.
  3. Subscript 50, denotes a one off intervention at age 50.
  4. RX denotes the availabily of treatments for cancers in addition to the intervention program.
  5. Efficacy varied slightly between regions due to demographic differences.
  6. Efficacy considered on an age-sex specific basis.
  7. a) Denotes colonoscopy performed on all positive tests, with subsequent removal of lesions or polyps if discovered.
  8. b) Including surgical, radiotherapy and chemotherapy.
  9. c) In excess of decrease in CFR caused by treatment.
  10. d) Varies by region