From: A systemmatic literature review on indirect costs of women with breast cancer
No. | First author | Study population | Databases | Perspective | Type of study | Discount rate | Region | Income groups | Sample size |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Lidgren (2007) [45] | Female patients with a previous diagnosis of breast cancer | Enrolled | Societal | Prospective | – | Sweden | High income: OECD | 361 |
2 | Ivanauskiene (2010) [40] | A survey of 379 women treated in five major Lithuanian hospitals | Questionnaire | Societal | Prospective | – | Lithuania | High income: nonOECD | 379 |
3 | Broekx (2011) [38] | All women had undergone an initial surgical treatment for breast cancer between 1998 and 2003, allowing us to identify these patients in the Christian Health Insurance Funds databases based on the official billing codes attached to these surgical procedures | Enrolled | Societal | Prospective | 4% | Belgium | High income: OECD | 20,439 |
4 | Jain (2016) [55] | The patients with primary diagnosis as breast cancer, diagnosed in between April 2012 to March 2013, not having any co-morbidities | Interview | Houshold | Prospective | – | India | Lower middle income | 221 |
5 | Łyszczarz (2017) [35] | Population based | Social insurance system and Polish National Cancer Registry | Societal | Retrospective | 0%, 3.5% | Poland | High income: OECD | – |
6 | Vondeling (2018) [52] | Women with breast cancer in netherlands | Dutch National Cancer Registry | – | Retrospective | 2%, 6% | Netherlands | High income: OECD | 320,179 |
7 | Roine (2019) [58] | All patients aged 18 years and over and diagnosed with BC were eligible for the study | questionnair | – | Prospective | – | Finland | High income: OECD | 827 |
8 | Trogdon (2020) [51] | women with no missing responses to questions regarding having ever been diagnosed with cancer, having ever been diagnosed with breast cancer, and age at breast cancer diagnosis | National Health Interview Survey | Social | Retrospective | 3% | United States | High income: OECD | 6935 |
9 | Max (2009) [46] | California women for 2001 using California specific hospitalization and mortality data | California specific hospitalization and mortality data | – | Retrospective | 3% | United States | High income: OECD | 12,934 |
10 | Meadows (2010) [57] | employed women, aged 18 to 64, with BC identified by a validated algorithm between 1999 and 2005, from claims (Market Scan) and attendance databases | Encounters (CC&E) and Health and Productivity Management (HPM) databases from Thomson Reuters | Employer | Reteospective | – | United States | High income: OECD | 880 |
11 | Sorensen (2012) [50] | The incident cohort of MBC patients included both de novo MBC patients and MBC patients who progressed during that year from earlier stages of breast cancer | Medical record | Social | – | 3% | United States | High income: OECD | 49,674 |
12 | Heras (2018) [60] | Patients with newly diagnosed or recurrent mBC diagnosed over 1 year | Physician survey conducted with 10 clinical experts in Spain | Spain | High income: OECD | 2923 | |||
13 | Gordon (2007) [54] | English-speaking women recently diagnosed with unilateral breast cancer, aged 20–75 years and who resided within a 100 km radius of Brisbane (where approximately 70% of the Queensland population resides) | Questionnaire | The perspective of the survivor | Prospective | – | Australia | High income: OECD | 287 |
14 | Wan (2013) [31] | Adult BC patients eligible for employee benefits of sick leave and/or short-term disability were identified with ICD-9 codes | The MarketScan_ Health and Productivity Management database | societal | Retrospective | – | United State | High income: OECD | 326,903 |
15 | Binazzi (2013) [53] | Only subjects over 25 years deceased in 2006 have been selected by cancer site | Italian National Institute of Statistics | – | Retrospective | 1%, 3% | Italy | High income: OECD | 11,476 death |
16 | Mahmood (2018) [56] | Patients were eligible for inclusion if they were (1) female; (2) 18 years of age or older; (3) had been in treatment for 3 months to 2 years since diagnosis; (4) were diagnosed with metastatic breast cancer with any stage; (5) fluent in Urdu, English or regional languages i.e. Punjabi and Saraiki; and (6) able to provide informed consent | Qeustionnair | – | Prospective | – | Pakistan | Lower middle income | 200 |
17 | Goyal (2020) [61] | Patients with MBC was ascertained based on the presence of at least two claims with an ICD-9-CM diagnosis code for secondary malignancy | The IBM MarketScan Commercial Claims and Encounters (CCAE) databases | – | Retrospective | – | United State | High income: OECD | 5563 |
18 | Ferrier (2020) [32] | Female patients with histologically confirmed, previously untreated and primarily operable BC (exclusion of metastatic, locally advanced or inflammatory BC as defined by the AJCC) | Questionnaire | Socetial | Prospective | France | High income: OECD | 168 | |
19 | Daroudi (2015) [10] | Cancer population | National cancer registry reports, hospital records, occupational data, and interviews with expert | Iran | Upper middle income | 39,316 | |||
20 | Yin (2017) [59] | The study sample included employees who had at least two inpatient or outpatient claims with a diagnosis of BC | The MarketScan_ Health and Productivity Management database | Employer | Retrospective | – | United State | High income: OECD | 6409 |
21 | Oliva (2006) [47] | Spanish Registry of Deaths by cause | – | Retrospective | 0%, 3%, 6% | Spain | High income: OECD | 38,025 | |
22 | Hanly (2012) [39] | Population-based sample of 1373 survivors was selected from the National Cancer Registry Ireland. Survivors were between 6 months and 2 years since diagnosis and had been treated at 1 of 17 hospitals across the country (14 mixed public/ private, 3 private) | Questionnaire | Societal (HCA) and an employer’s (FCA) perspective | Prospective | 4% | Irland | High income: OECD | 250 |
23 | KIM (2007) [43] | All cancer population | Health Insurance Review agency & Korean Central Cancer Registry (KCCR) | Social | Retrospective | 3% | Korea | High income: OECD | 36,226 |
24 | Pearce (2016) [48] | Cancer population | Central Statistics Office (CSO) and annual age-specific cancer | – | Retrospective & prospective | 5% | Ireland | High income: OECD | Cancer death 2011–2030 |
25 | Bradley (2008) [33] | All cancer population | National Interim Projections, Berkeley Mortality Database, Current Population Survey (CPS) | – | Retrospective | 3% | United State | High income: OECD | – |
26 | Hanly (2014) [36] | Cancer deaths | WHO mortality database | Social | Retrospective | 3.5% | Europe | – | – |
27 | Lee (2014) [44] | Women with breast cancer | national health insurance claims data | Societal | Retrospective | 3% | Korea | High income: OECD | 42,605 in 2000, 97,507 in 2010 |
28 | Khorasani (2015) [42] | Cancer population | Iranian Ministry of Cooperation Labor and Social Welfare | Social | Retrospective | 3% | Iran | Upper middle income | 3304 |
29 | Karami-matin (2016) [41] | Cancer people | Ministry of Health and Medical Education (MoHME) & Iranian Ministry of Cooperation Labor and Social Welfare | – | Retrospective | 3% | Iran | Upper middle income | 962 in 2006, 1,086 in 2007, 1,122 in 2008, 1,124 in 2009, 1,283 in 2010 |
30 | Sasser (2005) [49] | Female employees, also age 50–64 years (the “comparison group”), during the 3-year period | Medical record | Employer | Retrospective | – | United State | High income: OECD | 555 |
31 | Luengo (2013) [34] | Population based | International and national sources | – | – | European Union | – | – | |
32 | John (2010) [62] | Cancer population | WHO | – | Retrospective | – | Global | – | – |
33 | Barchuk (2019) [37] | Cancer population | Herzen Research Institute of Oncology | Societal burden of cancer in Russia | Retrospective | 0% & 5% | Russia | High income: nonOECD | 2031 |