Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 3 Economic evaluation methods of included studies

From: Primary and secondary prevention interventions for cardiovascular disease in low-income and middle-income countries: a systematic review of economic evaluations

Author, pub year Type of evaluation Design Type of modelling/design Time horizon Perspective Discounting (%) Uncertainty analysis [# iterations] Currency and year Method of CE
Permanicha et al. 2015 CUA and CEA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Provider 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [1000] Thai baht, 2013 WTP
Anderson et al. 2000 CEA Modelling Pharmacoeconomic analysis 1 year Private sector healthcare funder Not stated Rands, 1999 Not stated
Mason et al. 2014 CEA Modelling Macro (Markov) 10 years Healthcare provider 3 Not stated Int. dollar, 2010 Not stated
Donaldson et al. 2011 CEA Modelling Macro 10 years Societal (no productivity loss estimated) 3 Not stated US dollar, 2008 Not stated
Yan et al. 2015 CEA Empirical Retrospective Not stated Healthcare provider One-way sensitivity [-] Chinese Yuan, 2008 WHO 3xGDP
Bautista LE et al. 2013 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Healthcare system 3 One-way sensitivity [–] US dollar Not stated
Anderson et al. 2000 CUA and CEA Modelling Pharmacoeconomic analysis 3.8 years Private sector healthcare provider 5 Not stated Rands, 1999 Not stated
Basu S et al. 2016 CUA Modelling Microsimulation Lifetime Healthcare provider 3 PSA [10,000] US dollar, 2005 WHO 3xGDP
Khonputsa et al. 2012 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Healthcare 3 PSA [2000] Thai baht, 2004 WHO 3xGDP
Rabus et al. 2005 CEA Empirical Retrospective 1 year Government PSA [1000] Euro, 1999 Not stated
Gaziano et al. 2006 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Societal (no productivity loss estimated) 3 PSA [Not stated] US dollar, 2001 WHO 3xGDP
Gaziano et al. 2015 CUA Modelling Microsimulation Lifetime Healthcare 3 Deterministic sensitivity [–] US dollar, 2013 WHO 3xGDP
Li et al. 2015 CUA and CEA Modelling Micro (discrete-event simulation) Lifetime Healthcare 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [1000] US dollar, 2013 WHO 3xGDP
Ortegon et al. 2012 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Healthcare 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [Not stated] Int. dollar, 2005 WHO 3xGDP
Permsuwan et al. 2015 CUA Modelling Macro (Decision tree & Markov) Lifetime Societal 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [1000] Thai baht, 2013 WTP
Ha et al. 2011 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Societal 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [1000] Vietnamese Dong, 2007 WHO 3xGDP
Schulman-Marcus et al. 2010 CUA Modelling Macrosimulation Lifetime Societal (no productivity loss & transport estimated) 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [Not stated] US dollar, 2007 WHO 3xGDP
Jafar et al. 2011 CEA Empirical RCT Not stated Societal 5 Bayesian PSA [1000] US dollar 2007 WHO 3xGDP
Choosakulchart et al. 2013 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Societal 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [10,000] Thai baht, 2010 WTP
Lakic et al. 2012 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Third party payer 5 PSA [10,000] Serbian dinar, 2009 WHO 3xGDP
Pan et al. 2014 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Healthcare 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [10,000] Chinese Yuan, 2011 WHO 3xGDP
Wilcox et al. 2015 CEA Modelling Macro (Markov) 10 years Healthcare 3 Multiway sensitivity analysis Int. dollar, 2010 WHO 3xGDP
Gaziano et al. 2005 CEA Modelling Macro (Markov) 10 years Healthcare 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [1000] US dollar, 2001 WHO 3xGDP
Amirsadri and Hassani 2015 CUA and CEA Modelling Macro (semi-Markov) Lifetime Healthcare 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [10,000] US dollar, 2014 WHO 3xGDP
Wu et al. 2014 CUA Modelling Microsimulation Lifetime Health system 3 Deterministic (one-way) & PSA [1000] US dollar, 2012 WHO 3xGDP
Mejia et al. 2015 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) 10 years Healthcare 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [Not stated] Colombian Peso, 2010 WHO 3xGDP
Salomon et al. 2012 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Societal (no productivity loss estimated) 3 Not stated Int. dollar, 2005 WHO 3xGDP
Gu et al. 2015 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) 10 years Healthcare 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [1000] Int. dollar, 2015 WHO 3xGDP
Nguyen et al. 2016 CUA Modelling Macro (Decision tree and Markov) 10 years and Lifetime Health service 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [5000] Int. dollar, 2013 WTP
Davies et al. 2013 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Healthcare system 3 Deterministic sensitivity analysis [–] Euros, 2011 WTP
Jarungsuccess et al. 2014 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Government and Societal (no productivity loss estimated) 3 PSA [5000] Thai baht, 2013 WHO 3xGDP
Wang et al. 2013 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Societal (no productivity loss estimated) Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [1000] US dollar, 2013 WHO 3xGDP
Robberstad et al. 2007 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Healthcare 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [5000] US dollar, 2005 WHO 3xGDP
Ngalesoni et al. 2016 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Provider and Societal (no productivity loss estimated) 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [Not stated] US dollar, 2012 WHO 3xGDP
Tolla et al. 2016 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Healthcare provider 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [1000] US dollar, 2012 WHO 3xGDP
Rubinstein et al. 2010 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) 5 years Healthcare system 3 PSA [1000] Int. dollar, 2007 WHO 3xGDP
Basu et al. 2015 CUA Modelling Micro (Discrete-event simulation) 20 years Societal (no productivity loss estimated) 3 PSA [10,000] US dollar, 2014 WHO 3xGDP
Rosendaal et al. 2010 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) 10 years Healthcare provider 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [1000] US dollar, 2012 WHO 3xGDP
Ekwunife et al. 2013 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) 30 years Third party payer 3 PSA [1000] US dollar, 2010 WTP
Amirsadri and Sedighi 2017 CUA and CEA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Healthcare provider 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [Not stated] US dollar, 2015 WHO 3xGDP
Wang et al. 2017 CEA Empirical RCT Not stated Healthcare Not stated US dollar, 2013 Not stated
Polanczyk et al. 2007 CEA Modelling Macro (Decision tree and Markov) 1 year and lifetime Private and public health payers 3 PSA [10,000] Brazilian reais, 2003 Not stated
Garcia-Pena et al. 2002 CEA Empirical RCT Not stated Health service and patient Not stated Mexican pesos,1998 Not stated
Ribeiro et al. 2010 CUA and CEA Modelling Macro (Markov) 20 years Public healthcare system 3 Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [1000] US dollar, 2007 WHO 3xGDP
Araujo et al. 2008 CEA Modelling Macro (Markov) 1 and 20 years Healthcare system Not stated Brazilian reais, 2005 Not stated
Araujo et al. 2007 CEA Modelling Macro (Markov) 20 years Healthcare system 7 Not stated Brazilian reais, 2007 Not stated
Murray et al. 2003 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) Lifetime Not stated 3 Multivariate sensitivity analysis [–] Int. dollar, WHO 3xGDP
Akkazieva et al. 2009 CUA Modelling Macro (Markov) 10 years Not stated Not stated Kyrgygstan Som, 2005 WHO 3xGDP
Gonzalez-Diaz et al. 2015 CEA Empirical retrospective Not stated Health service provider Deterministic (one-way) and PSA [1000] US dollar, 2014 WTP
Huang and Ren 2010 CBA Empirical Retrospective Not stated Healthcare Not stated Chinese Yuan, 1997 Not stated
  1. CUA cost-utility analysis, CEA cost-effectiveness analysis, CBA cost–benefit analysis, RCT randomized controlled trial, PSA probabilistic sensitivity analysis, WTP willingness to pay, WHO World Health Organization, GDP Gross domestic product