Skip to main content

Table 1 Main characteristics of the included studies

From: Personalized medicine in colorectal cancer diagnosis and treatment: a systematic review of health economic evaluations

Study

Country

Population

Type of test

Alberts et al. [36]

USA

CRC patients with stage II, T3, MMR-P

Oncotype DX (12-gene assay)

Barone et al. [34]

IT

High-risk non-mCRC patients

KRAS mutation testing

Barzi et al. [17]

USA

Healthy individuals

IHC, Amsterdam criteria, MMR, PREMM, germline, BRAF, MSI, RBG

Behl et al. [33]

USA

Patients with mCRC

KRAS and BRAF mutation testing

Blank et al. [31]

CH

Patients with mCRC who are chemorefractory

KRAS and BRAF mutation testing

Dinh et al. [27]

USA

Population aged 20 years or over

Genetic sequencing and rearrangement; single-site testing; IHC; MSI

Gallego et al. [18]

USA

CRC patients with genetic mutations

NGS; IHC; BRAF V600E

Gausachs et al. [19]

NR (Probably ES)

CRC patients with genetic mutations

BRAF V600E, MLH1 promoter hypermethylation

Gould-Suarez et al. [20]

USA

CRC patients

RBG, BRAF targeted mutation analysis, IHC; MSI, MMR gene sequencing

Gudgeon et al. [21]

USA

CRC patients

IHC staining for the 4 MMR proteins, MSI, BRAF mutation, MMR gene sequencing/rearrangement analyses (Seq-Rearr), and methylation of the MLH1 promoter. (tumor testing and genetic testing)

Ladabaum et al. [28]

USA

CRC patients and their relatives

Amsterdam, IHC, BRAF, MSI, MMR, PREMM, RBG

Leenen et al. [22]

DE

CRC patients

MSI, IHC, MMR gene sequencing, RBG

Severin et al. [23]

DE

CRC patients and their relatives

IHC, MSI, BRAF V600 mutation, genetic sequencing, MMR, Amsterdam criteria, RBG

Sie et al. [24]

DE

CRC patients and their relatives

IHC, MSI, MLH1, germline

Snowsill et al. [26]

UK, Wal

CRC patients aged under 50 years and their FDRs

MSI, IHC, BRAF V600E, Amsterdam criteria

Snowsill et al. [25]

UK

CRC patients aged under 50 years

IHC, MSI, BRAF

Vijayaraghavan et al. [32]

USA, DE

Patients with mCRC in 2nd-line treatment

KRAS mutation testing

Wang et al. [29]

USA

CRC patients (at a mean age of 48 years in the base case) and their relatives (at a mean age of 25 years)

IHC, BRAF, MSI, RBG, Amsterdam criteria, MMRpredict, MMRpro, PREMM, germline

Wang et al. [30]

SG

21-year-old FDRs of mutation-confirmed LS cases

NR

Westwood et al. [35]

UK, Wal

Adult mCRC whose metastases are confined to liver and are unresectable

KRAS mutation testing

  1. USA United States, IT Italy, CH Switzerland, ES Spain, DE Germany, UK United Kingdom, Wal Wales, SG Singapore, CRC Colorectal cancer, mCRC metastatic Colorectal cancer, MMR-P mismatch-repair-proficient, LS Lynch syndrome, FDRs first-degree relatives, NR not reported, NGS next-generation-sequencing, RBG Revised Bethesda Guidelines