From: Cost-effectiveness of human papillomavirus vaccination in Germany
Vaccination strategy | Comparator (coverage in 12-year-old girls, no vaccination of boys), % | Incremental cases prevented (undiscounted) | ICER (€/QALY) | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bivalent vaccination | Quadrivalent vaccination | |||||||||||
Coverage in 12-year-old girls, % | Coverage in 12-year-old boys, % | Cervical cancer | Cervical cancer death | Health care payer perspective | Societal perspective | Health care payer perspective | Societal perspective | |||||
2 doses | 3 doses | 2 doses | 3 doses | 2 doses | 3 doses | 2 doses | 3 doses | |||||
50 (base case) | 0 (base case) | 0 (base case) | 99,914 | 23,703 | 19,450 | 34,249 | 13,248 | 28,047 | 3645 | 14,711 | Cost-saving | 8984 |
50 | 20 | 50 | 16,899 | 4396 | 67,129 | 105,794 | 61,077 | 99,742 | 58,549 | 94,186 | 52,648 | 88,284 |
50 | 50 | 50 | 32,923 | 8628 | 83,602 | 130,449 | 77,607 | 124,453 | 73,973 | 117,240 | 68,118 | 111,386 |
50 | 80 | 50 | 37,335 | 9906 | 110,977 | 171,424 | 105,091 | 165,538 | 98,369 | 153,849 | 92,625 | 148,105 |
20 | 0 | 0 | 46,844 | 10,815 | 15,659 | 28,568 | 9410 | 22,318 | Cost-saving | 3387 | Cost-saving | Cost-saving |
20 | 20 | 20 | 28,308 | 7110 | 34,669 | 57,024 | 28,663 | 51,019 | 19,892 | 37,985 | 14,223 | 32,316 |
20 | 50 | 20 | 68,041 | 17,040 | 37,066 | 60,682 | 30,959 | 54,574 | 26,478 | 46,965 | 20,617 | 41,104 |
20 | 80 | 20 | 87,611 | 22,065 | 46,525 | 74,844 | 40,440 | 68,758 | 36,033 | 61,027 | 30,164 | 55,158 |
80 | 0 | 0 | 133,226 | 32,295 | 25,028 | 42,605 | 18,873 | 36,450 | 10,562 | 24,412 | 4798 | 18,648 |
80 | 20 | 80 | 2157 | 658 | 313,627 | 475,013 | 308,346 | 469,732 | 269,103 | 410,286 | 263,974 | 405,157 |
80 | 50 | 80 | 4365 | 1332 | 364,237 | 550,917 | 358,953 | 545,633 | 311,264 | 473,605 | 306,138 | 468,478 |
80 | 80 | 80 | 5934 | 1809 | 413,018 | 624,085 | 407,724 | 618,790 | 352,012 | 534,785 | 346,880 | 529,653 |