Skip to main content

Table 2 Critical appraisal results for included studies using the JBI critical appraisal checklist for economic evaluations

From: Advancing aged care: a systematic review of economic evaluations of workforce structures and care processes in a residential care setting

Source Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q5 Q6 Q7 Q8 Q9 Q10 Q11
Well-defined question Comprehensive description of alternatives All important and relevant costs and outcomes identified Clinical effectiveness established Costs and outcomes measured accurately Costs and outcomes valued credibly Costs and outcomes adjusted for differential timing Incremental analysis of costs and consequences Sensitivity analyses conducted Study results include all issues of concern to users Results are generalizable
Chenoweth et al. [31]; Norman et al. [32] Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes N/A Yes Yes Yes Yes
Chenoweth et al. [39] Yes Yes No No Unclear Yes N/A No No No Unclear
Dorr et al. [20] Yes Yes No Yes No Yes N/A No Yes No Yes
Grabowski and O’Malley [34] Yes Yes Yes Yes No Unclear No No No No Unclear
Jenkens et al. [36] Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes N/A No No Yes Yes
Maas et al. [23]; Swanson et al. [38]; Swanson et al. [44] Yes Yes Yes No Unclear Unclear N/A No No No Unclear
MacNeil Vroomen et al. [22] Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear Yes N/A Yes Yes Yes Unclear
Mehr and Fries [24] Yes Yes Yes No Yes Unclear N/A No No Yes Unclear
Molloy et al. [25] No Yes Yes No Yes Unclear No No No Yes Unclear
Müller et al. [33] Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ouslander et al. [43] No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes N/A No No Yes Unclear
Paulus et al. [21] Yes Yes No No Yes Unclear Unclear No No No Unclear
Przybylski et al. [28] Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear Unclear No No No Yes Unclear
Rantz et al. [26] Yes Yes No Yes No Unclear No No No No No
Rovner et al. [27] Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear Unclear N/A No No Yes Unclear
Schneider et al. [35] No Yes Yes No Yes Yes N/A No No Yes No
Sharkey et al. [37] Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes N/A No No No Unclear
Teresi et al. [29] Yes Yes No Yes No Unclear Unclear No Yes No No
van de Ven et al. [30] No Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear No No No Unclear Unclear