Skip to main content

Table 1 Model parameters: estimates of the probability of the events

From: Modelling the cost-effectiveness of a new infant vaccine to prevent tuberculosis disease in children in South Africa

 

Probability % (range)

Reference

ARI and Annual risk of re-infection

3 (2-4)

[22–25] and expert opiniona

Progressing to pulmonary TB

  

Age

 

Assuming an ARI of 3%, calculated using the provincial government Western Cape Department of Health electronic TB database, and expert opiniona

 0-2

54.19

 3-5

20.37

 6-10

6.60

Progressing to miliary TB

 

Age

 

 0-2

0.22

 3-5

0.10

 6-10

0.04

Progressing to TB meningitis

 

Age

 

 0-2

0.52

 3-5

0.14

 6-10

0.10

Dying from pulmonary TB

 

Age

 

 <3

0.75

 3-5

0.09

 >6

0.59

[26] , the provincial government Western Cape Department of Health electronic TB database, and expert opiniona

Dying from miliary TB

 

Age

 

 <3

23.53

 3-5

9.09

 >6

16.66

Dying from TB meningitis

 

Age

 

 <3

25.00

 3-5

26.66

 >6

20.00

Dying from other causes

 

South African 2009 Life Tables [27] and adjusted to remove the risk of dying from TB, and expert opiniona

Age

 

 0-1

0.0429

 1-2

0.0047

 3-4

0.0049

 5

0.0014

 6-10

0.0014

 10

0.0012

MVA85A efficacy against disease

17.3 (12.3 – 22.3)b

Up-take BCG

 

[21]

Up-take MVA85A

99.0 (98.5 – 99.5)

[28]

Drop-out rate DTP3 to MCV

85.0 (76.4 – 89.5)

Calculated

Discount rate_outcomes

14.0 (9.5 – 23.1)

[29]

Discount rate_costs

3 (0 – 6)

[30]

 

3 (0 – 6)

[30]

  1. aExpert opinion provided by Professor Willem Hanekom, Dr Mark Hatherill, Professor Anneke Hesseling, Professor Helen McShane, Dr Hassan Mohammed, Dr Roxana Rustomjee, and Dr Michele Tameris.
  2. bIn order to assess the sensitivity of the ICER to the vaccine efficacy, we randomly assigned a range of +/-5% to the clinical trial efficacy of 17.3%.