Skip to main content

Table 1 Studies identified in the literature and included in the analysis

From: From efficacy to equity: Literature review of decision criteria for resource allocation and healthcare decisionmaking

Studies reporting on decision criteria

Studies describing a decisionmaking tool

Authors

Type of study and level of decisionmaking*

1. Andreae et al. [9], 2009

Survey, macro

1. Bowen et al. [15], 2005

2. Asante et al. [8], 2009

Interviews, meso & macro

2. Browman et al. [16], 2008

3. Baltussen et al. [12], 2007

Focus group, macro

3. Ghaffar et al. [17], 2010

4. Baltussen et al. [30], 2006

Focus group, meso & macro

4. Goetghebeur et al. [10, 18], 2008,2010

5. Baltussen et al. [11], 2006

Methodology

5. Golan et al. [19], 2010

6. Dionne et al. [31], 2009

Interviews, macro

6. Hailey et al. [20], 2009

7. Dolan et al. [32], 2010

Methodology

7. Honore et al. [21], 2010

8. Duthie et al. [33], 1997

Interviews, micro, meso & macro

8. Johnson et al. [22], 2009

9. Gibson et al. [34], 2006

Focus group & interviews, meso & macro

9. Kirby et al. [23], 2008

10. Hofmann et al. [35], 2005

Literature review

10. Meagher et al. [24], 2010

11. Irving et al. [36], 2010

Interviews, micro

11. Menon et al. [25], 2010

12. Jehu-Appiah et al. [37], 2008

Focus group, macro

12. Tannahill et al. [26], 2008

13. Kapiriri et al. [38], 2009

Interviews, micro, meso & macro

13. The University of York [27], 2002

14. Koopmanschap et al. [39], 2010

Focus group, macro

14. Wilson et al. [28], 2006

15. Lasry et al. [14], 2010

Interviews, macro

 

16. Lehoux et al. [40], 2007

Literature review

 

17. Lopert et al. [41], 2009

Focus group, macro

 

18. Martin et al. [42], 2001

Focus group, macro

 

19. Mitton et al. [43], 2006

Focus group, macro

 

20. Mullen et al. [44], 2004

Survey, meso

 

21. Noorani et al. [45], 2007

Literature review and interviews, macro

 

22. Saarni et al. [46], 2008

Consensus procedure, macro

 

23. Vuorenkoski et al. [47], 2008

Literature review

 

24. Wilson et al. [48], 2007

Focus group, macro

 

25. Wirtz et al. [49], 2005

Interviews, macro

 

26. Youngkong et al. [13], 2009

Literature review

 
  1. *Survey, interviews and focus groups were performed with healthcare decisionmakers making decisions at national or regional level (macro level), at a healthcare facility level (meso level) and/or at the healthcare provider level (micro level).